maemo.org Bugzilla – Bug 1142
Impossible to add authenticated RSS feeds (username & password)
Last modified: 2011-04-14 15:06:14 UTC
You need to
before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.
RSS & atom feeds coming from a webserver which requires login are not supported
by the newsreader.
Indeed, this is still a problem. For example, I use Livejournal's RSS feeds to
keep track of my friends and their blogs however there are some posts which are
private and can only be read by certain friends. You must be logged in to read
Currently, the RSS feed reader sees the public posts. I'll be adding more
information to this bug soon along with some test cases to help fix it.
Looking at the Liferea FAQ site (http://liferea.sourceforge.net/faq.htm),
you'll notice the following:
Q: I want cookies!
A: Liferea supports cookies provided by a text file ~/.liferea_1.2/cookies.txt
which contains cookies in Netscape format. The easiest way is to copy the file
from your Mozilla profile after you created the cookies with the browser.
I figured that since we have the microb browser, we should be able to use this
trick. I did indeed find the cookies.txt file and copied it into
.osso_rss_feed_reader but it didn't seem to change anything. It's entirely
possible that the code to do this wasn't implemented in the version used by
Maemo or that it's still actually looking for ~/.liferea_version... which I
haven't tried yet.
If someone gives it a shot, please let us know.
Which exact version and hardware is this about? Does this also happen with
Hmm, anybody able to create an example URL / example login? :-/
Anybody can answer my questions, please? :)
I'd love to have a URL to test this.
Are these authenticated feeds always in https?
I'm tempted of putting Bug 2807 and Bug 3885 as dependencies of this one, but I
don't know whether "a webserver which requires login" = "https"
Anyway, perhaps it is better to centraliz the discussion in Bug 3885 since it
is better reported and followed.
Resolving as DUPLICATE. Please reopen if you disagree.
*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of bug 3885 ***
(In reply to comment #5)
> Are these authenticated feeds always in https?
No, although the most common HTTP authentication method (Basic) sends the
password essentially in the clear so in most cases they should be (then again
people seem happy to use FTP, POP etc even on public hotspots so what do I
know). But transport encryption (HTTPS) and authentication are separate
issues, thus reopening.
Just to muddy the waters it's also possible to do HTTPS authentication with SSL
client certificates, but let's cross that bridge when we come to it.
So can I please get a test URL for this?
Try <http://home.maneos.org/maemo-bug-1142/test.rss> using "a" as both the
username & password.
Thanks a lot!
Confirming - this is a HTTP feed, can be opened in browser, but adding it to
RSS reader shows "Unable to add feed. Address invalid."
http://a:firstname.lastname@example.org/maemo-bug-1142/test.rss does not work either.
Filed an internal ticket (and expecting an "It was never a requirement to
implement this" answer, but maybe Nokia will surprise me).
WONTFIX for Maemo5 according to Nokia. Now need to find out if this is still
valid in Harmattan (the version after Maemo5)...
Harmattan (the software version after Maemo5) will show an error message:
“Unable to access feed. Authentication not supported”.
So it's not planned to add HTTPS support for Harmattan, but you will at least
get a less vague error message.
Plus according to Nokia this unfortunately is a WONTFIX for Maemo5.