maemo.org Bugzilla – Full Text Bug Listing
|Summary:||Anonymous users don't see favs|
|Product:||[Websites] maemo.org Website||Reporter:||Quim Gil <quim.gil>|
|Component:||News||Assignee:||Oskari Kokko <oskari.kokko>|
|Status:||CLOSED FIXED||QA Contact:|
Anonymous users don't see favs. Only logging in you see the whole stuff.
(this comment had been placen in another bug, my mistake) Setting to P1. I think this functionality is crucial, since otherwise regular users don't see the fave hearts and they don't notice their own role in the maemo social news. After the first boom of favoriting we are seeing how this is decreasing. That was expected but we can get to almost zero if users don't see those little hearts.
Assigning to myself. Should've been dealt with by http://trac.midgard-project.org/changeset/11611 but needs more investigation.
Fixed, now fav icon points to https also for anon users.
Cool, but still a couple of details missing. 1. You click on a heart as anonymous. 2. You get the login window. That's ok for registered users, but we need to provide something for the potential non-registered users. They might be a majority, at least in the short term. 3. You go to the favorites step to confirm (I still don't see why this confirmation but this is another bug/RFE) 4. After ok you are left back to the logged-out screen! You don't see your heart red and your fav counted. 5. If you click again (because you think something went wrong) the page won't change at all, nor will give an error message that would tell you what's going on. The solution of course is to kept users in https once they are logged in.
A related issue (I can file a bug apart if you want, but it's just a new case of the same problem described before): 1. Log in 2. Fav an item. 3. Log off. 4. Fav the same item as anonymous. EXPECTED: a message telling me that I have already faved that item. ACTUAL RESULT: nothing happens. There is a variant: 1. Log in 2. Fav an item. 3. Log off. 4. Clean cookies, sessions, etc or simply pick another browser / computer. 5. As anonymous fav the same item. 6. Fill the login and press ok. Same expected and actual results. This might be confusing to users not remembering that they had already favorited a news story days/weeks ago.
Can you also please comment on the possibility of having the Ajax solution everybody wants to see there? I know it's not written in the requirements, I want to know how far are we from having this lovely feature in place. I was even thinking that the work flow could go like this: 1. Anonymous user favs item 2. Heart turns red and counts go +1 instantly, making the user happy. They are though temporary values, a trick while the user identifies himself. 3. Login/register window appears, telling the user that needs to identify in order to store values to their favorites. 3a. If user identifies, values are stored and available in her Favorites page. 3b. If user don't, values are deleted after... 1h? Registered users should only see hearts turning red and +1 counts instantly. No need to extra Favorites confirmation page. Just fav, fav, fav!
The AJAX solution is definitely doable, but not within the constraints of the current project. We have to think of assigning some retainer time or something else for it a bit later. Marking bug as LATER to keep it in store.
Alright, the AJAX thing for later. But please don't ignore the issues reported in between.
The actual issue of anonymous users not seeing favs has been addressed. Other issues should be reported in their own bugs.
Fave process sends you back to anonymous after logging in https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1969 fav hearts turning red instantly https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1970
Regression: the hearts in the right column 'latest' are not visible to anonymous users anymore. They are visible in the highlights, though. See: http://maemo.org/news/
*** Bug 1994 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Ok, but not exactly a duplicate. Let's just not forget that apart from the right column, announcements like http://maemo.org/news/announcements/view/1190039774.html also should have a heart/bury. And the news in the home, but I assume this will be discussed when we define the home.
Regression: now you can't see the fav/bury icons in the right column even if you are logged in. It would be good to see why this regression has happened once again and make sure it doesn't happen a third time.
Please fix this regression asap. Thanks!
The regression came from the Favourites folder getting hidden from navigation, meaning that all elements where the location of that folder is not "hardcoded" are unable to find it, and so don't display favs. We are fixing this today.
Fixed, sidebar has favorites now
Closing FIXED bugs. if error/problem still occurs, please reopen bug with comments.